Passenger in Drunk Driver vehicle failing to wear seat belt found 40% responsible for own injuries.

In the case of Gallagher v McGeady the Irish High Court ruled that the Plaintiff was guilty of contributory negligence in the amount of 40% for allowing herself to be a passenger in a car where the driver had consumed alcohol, and for not wearing a seatbelt, causing injury.

 

Ryan J had heard from Counsel that in cases where the passengers allowed themselves to be carried by persons under the influence there are decisions ranging from 30% to 50% Contributory Negligence, and in the worst case scenario there is precedent of up to 55% Contributory negligence for failure to wear a seatbelt. Unfortunately the judgement did not cite the relevant authorities quoted by Counsel in the case.

 

The leading case concerning a passenger in a vehicle driven by a drunk driver is Hussey v Twomey, a decision of the Supreme Court, reported by this blog here: http://laceysolicitors.typepad.com/insurance-law-ireland/2012/09/irl-recent-cases-in-pi-litigation-part-4-passenger-in-a-drink-driver-vehicle-the-case-of-hussey-v-twomey-and-others-20.html

 

The full judgement in Gallagher v McGeady can be read here:

 

http://www.courts.ie/Judgments.nsf/09859e7a3f34669680256ef3004a27de/9451186981c135ea80257b340055c097?OpenDocument

 

 Damian McGeady, Lacey Solicitors

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

css.php